The actor said in January 2019 that he was dating someone, but he didn’t identify who it was. McNally told My Devotional Thoughts at the time, “I am more focused on the puppies. As a result, I’m looking forward to spending as much time as possible at home with the new puppies that my girlfriend and I each adopted.

Krakow wished her TV hubby a happy birthday with three emojis of smiling faces with hearts. Andrea Brooks, who has been starring opposite McNally since he joined the show in 2019, sent out a series of pink heart emoticons.

McGarry, who joined the series in 2019 as the lovable Mountie, found love on the show. Wedding Veil actor Kayla Wallace and When Calls The Heart actress Kayla Wallace were rumored to be dating in November 2020.

Hallmark Channel performers like Erin Krakow, Chris McNally, and Kevin McGarry have become familiar faces over the course of the show’s more than nine seasons on the network. It premiered in 2014 and was renewed for a tenth season in June 2022.